What is the typical real estate commission?

Historically (pre-2024) the US standard was 5-6% of sale price, paid by the seller and split equally between listing agent and buyer's agent (typically 3% each). After the October 2023 Sitzer-Burnett verdict and the March 2024 NAR settlement, commissions are now expected to be negotiated separately between buyer and seller, with no MLS-mandated buyer-broker compensation. Effective August 2024, the new rules took effect — early 2026 data shows average total commissions trending toward 4-5%.

What was the Sitzer-Burnett verdict?

In October 2023, a Kansas City federal jury found NAR and several large brokerages liable for $1.8 billion in damages (trebled under antitrust law to $5.36 billion) for conspiring to inflate commissions through the MLS "cooperative compensation" rule. The case (Sitzer/Burnett v. National Association of Realtors et al.) ended decades of the "6% standard" cartel-like practice. NAR settled in March 2024 for $418 million and agreed to MLS rule changes effective August 2024.

Who pays the buyer's agent commission?

Historically, the SELLER paid both sides through the listing agreement, with MLS rules requiring buyer-broker compensation disclosure. Post-Sitzer (August 2024): the seller can still offer buyer-broker compensation, but it must be negotiated separately and is NOT mandated by MLS. Many buyers now hire and PAY their own agent directly via Buyer Representation Agreements. The CFPB and HUD published 2024 guidance clarifying that buyer-broker compensation cannot be financed into mortgage payments per current QM rules.

How does the commission split between agent and brokerage work?

Real estate agents are typically W-2 contractors of a brokerage. The agent's gross commission is split with the brokerage per their agreement. Typical splits: New agent 50/50 (agent gets 50%, brokerage 50%); experienced agent 70/30; high-producer 80/20 or 90/10; cap-style brokerages (Keller Williams, eXp, Compass) cap brokerage fees at $X/year then agent keeps 100%. Some brokerages also charge a desk fee or transaction fee. The Statement of Realty Disclosure (state-specific) requires disclosure to clients.

Can I negotiate real estate commission?

Yes — commissions have ALWAYS been negotiable by federal law (Sherman Antitrust Act, 1890; DOJ guidance via the 1947 NAR consent decree and subsequent). Post-Sitzer, negotiation is more common. Strategies: ask for a lower listing fee, find flat-fee MLS listings, agree to a higher fee tied to performance (above-asking sale), or use a buyer-rebate brokerage (legal in most states though banned in 10 states with anti-rebate laws). Top-producing agents often hold firm at 2.5-3%; new agents may discount to 1-2%.

Dual agency = same brokerage (or same agent) represents both buyer and seller in a transaction. It's legal in 42 US states with disclosure but banned in 8 (CO, FL, KS, MD, OK, TX, VT, WY). Critics argue dual agency creates conflicts of interest — the agent cannot fully advocate for both sides. Post-Sitzer Burnett the dual-agency model is under additional scrutiny. NAR's Code of Ethics Article 1 requires fiduciary duty; dual agents must navigate this with informed consent from both parties.

What is a flat-fee MLS listing?

Flat-fee MLS services charge sellers a one-time fee ($300-$1,500) to list on the MLS without buyer-broker cooperation or full-service brokerage. The seller handles showings, negotiation, and paperwork OR pays a la carte. Companies like Houzeo, Beycome, ISoldMyHouse.com offer this. Combined with a buyer-broker offering (e.g., 2.5% to buyer agent), total commission can drop to 2.5-3% vs the traditional 6%. The 2024 NAR settlement makes flat-fee even more attractive.

How is commercial real estate commission different?

Commercial transactions typically pay 4-6% commission on smaller deals ($1-5M), dropping to 2-4% on larger deals ($10M+) and 1-2% on institutional deals ($50M+). The commission may be paid based on a sliding scale (e.g., 6% on first $1M, 4% on next $4M, 2% above). Commercial brokers often hold the CCIM (Certified Commercial Investment Member) designation. Tenant representation in commercial leasing has its own commission structure — typically 3-5% of total lease value.

What is RESPA and how does it affect commission?

RESPA (Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, 1974) prohibits kickbacks and unearned fees in mortgage settlement. Real estate commissions themselves are NOT regulated by RESPA, but referral fees from agents to mortgage lenders, title companies, or home warranty providers ARE — they must be earned for actual services. RESPA violations can carry $10,000+ penalties. The CFPB enforces RESPA. The 2008 Dodd-Frank Act expanded CFPB authority over RESPA.

Are real estate commissions tax-deductible?

For the SELLER: Commission paid is a selling expense that reduces capital gain (via IRC § 1001 amount realized). On primary residence sales it reduces gain potentially below the IRC § 121 exclusion threshold ($250k single / $500k joint). On investment property sales it reduces taxable gain. For the BUYER: Generally NOT deductible currently; commission paid is added to the property's cost basis (which reduces future gain). For investors who hire buyer brokers under modern post-Sitzer agreements, the IRS treats it as a capitalized cost.

What is the history of real estate commission rates?

The 6% standard emerged in the mid-20th century as NAR (founded 1908) consolidated MLS practices nationwide. The DOJ investigated NAR repeatedly — 1947 NAR consent decree restricted price-fixing, but the "cooperative compensation" rule survived. The 2008-2010 housing crash and subsequent Zillow/Redfin/Compass disruption began commission compression. The DOJ filed antitrust suit against NAR in 2020 (settled). The 2023 Sitzer-Burnett verdict was the culmination of decades of antitrust scrutiny; the 2024 settlement triggered the end of the cartel-era commission structure.

What is a buyer-broker agreement post-Sitzer?

A written agreement between the buyer and their agent specifying: services to be provided, compensation structure (flat fee, hourly, percentage), and term length. Under post-Sitzer MLS rules (effective August 2024), buyer's agents typically must have a signed Buyer Representation Agreement BEFORE showing properties. The agreement can specify that seller-paid compensation (if offered) covers the fee, or that the buyer pays directly. NAR and state Realtor boards publish standard agreement templates.

Stacked-bar + pie widget · 6 commission structure presets

Real Estate Commission Calculator

Calculate the full real estate commission breakdown across buyer agent, listing agent, and their respective brokerages. The bespoke widget below renders a stacked horizontal bar showing each party's take, alongside a pie chart of the same distribution. Presets cover pre-Sitzer 6% standard, post-Sitzer-Burnett 2024 negotiated structures, flat-fee MLS, luxury, and commercial CCIM deals. The landmark October 2023 Sitzer-Burnett verdict and March 2024 NAR settlement reshaped US commission practices.

$27,000

Total commission

$13,500

Listing side

$13,500

Buyer side

$423,000

Seller net

Commission split.

Quick Conversion

FROM (Sale $)

TO (Commission $)27,000

Total %

Formula: Commission $ = Sale Price × Total Commission %

Commission stacked bar + pie distribution

Inputs

Sale price ($)

Total %

Buyer agent %

List agt split %

Buyer agt split %

Mode

Total commission

$27,000

6% of $450,000

Commission structure presets

Commission by sale price (6% standard)

Sale price	3% (each side)	5% total	6% total
$200k	$6,000	$10,000	$12,000
$300k	$9,000	$15,000	$18,000
$400k	$12,000	$20,000	$24,000
$500k	$15,000	$25,000	$30,000
$600k	$18,000	$30,000	$36,000
$750k	$22,500	$37,500	$45,000
$1000k	$30,000	$50,000	$60,000
$1500k	$45,000	$75,000	$90,000
$2000k	$60,000	$100,000	$120,000
$3000k	$90,000	$150,000	$180,000

See net of mortgage payoff: Mortgage Payoff →

Formula

Total = Sale Price × Total %Listing side = Sale × (Total − Buyer Agent %)Buyer side = Sale × Buyer Agent %Agent take = Side × Broker split %

Worked (pre-Sitzer 6%): $450k × 6% = $27,000 total. Buyer side $13,500 (3%), listing side $13,500 (3%). At 50/50 broker split: listing agent $6,750, listing brokerage $6,750, buyer agent $6,750, buyer brokerage $6,750. Seller net = $450k − $27k = $423,000 (before closing & payoff).

The history of real estate commissions — from 1908 NAR founding to post-Sitzer 2026

In 2026, a homeowner in Charlotte preparing to sell their $480,000 starter home faces very different commission math than they would have in 2023. Post-Sitzer-Burnett (the October 2023 verdict and the March 2024 NAR settlement), the historic 6% commission standard is gone. The seller can negotiate a 2-3% listing fee and either offer or decline buyer-broker compensation. This calculator helps visualize both pre- and post-Sitzer commission structures and their distributional consequences.

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) was founded in 1908 as the National Association of Real Estate Exchanges. Over the 20th century, NAR consolidated multi-listing service (MLS) practices, professional standards, and the "Realtor" trademark. The MLS "cooperative compensation" rule — that listing brokers must offer compensation to buyer brokers to participate in MLS — emerged in the mid-20th century and became the foundation of the 6% commission standard.

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has investigated NAR repeatedly for antitrust violations. The 1947 NAR consent decree barred explicit price-fixing of commission rates. The 1980s and 1990s saw additional DOJ scrutiny, particularly of MLS participation rules. In November 2020, the DOJ filed (and quickly settled) an antitrust suit against NAR — but the cooperative compensation rule survived. The Sitzer-Burnett plaintiffs picked up where DOJ stopped, suing under private antitrust law (Sherman Act Section 1).

On October 31, 2023, a federal jury in Kansas City awarded Sitzer-Burnett plaintiffs $1.8 billion in damages, trebled under the Clayton Act to $5.36 billion. The case (Sitzer/Burnett v. NAR, RE/MAX, Keller Williams, HomeServices of America, Anywhere Real Estate) found that NAR's cooperative compensation rule inflated commissions through cartel-like coordination. NAR settled in March 2024 for $418 million plus agreed MLS rule changes effective August 17, 2024.

The August 2024 NAR settlement rule changes: (1) MLSs may no longer display offers of buyer-broker compensation; (2) Buyer brokers must have signed Buyer Representation Agreements before showing properties (this rule was already in some states); (3) Buyer broker compensation must be negotiated separately and disclosed transparently. The changes don't prohibit seller-paid buyer-broker compensation, but they de-couple it from MLS participation.

Post-Sitzer market data through 2025-2026 shows total commissions trending from the historic 5.5-6.0% range toward 4.5-5.0%. The CFPB, FTC, and HUD published joint guidance in mid-2024 clarifying that buyer-broker commissions cannot be financed into mortgage payments per QM (Qualified Mortgage) rules — meaning buyers needing to pay buyer-broker fees must bring those funds to closing. The Fair Housing Act of 1968 continues to require non-discriminatory commission practices.

RESPA (Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act of 1974) continues to govern related settlement charges. RESPA Section 8 prohibits kickbacks and unearned fees in settlement services. The 2010 Dodd-Frank Act transferred RESPA enforcement to the CFPB. The 2024 changes do not affect RESPA but interact with it for closing disclosure requirements on Loan Estimate (LE) and Closing Disclosure (CD) forms. TILA (Truth in Lending Act) requires APR disclosure but does not regulate commissions directly.

How to compute commission

Enter sale price from the purchase contract.
Enter total commission % — typical 4-6% pre-Sitzer; 3-5% post-Sitzer.
Enter buyer-agent share — historically 50/50 split, now negotiable.
Enter broker splits — agent vs brokerage take from each side.
Read the stacked bar + pie. All four parties' takes visualized.

Real estate commission — frequently asked questions

Have more questions? Contact us

What brokers and agents say

4.9

Based on 5,950 reviews

“Explaining post-Sitzer commission negotiation to clients takes 15 minutes minimum. Your stacked-bar widget collapses that to 30 seconds. The pre-Sitzer vs post-Sitzer preset comparison is excellent for buyer education on the new compensation rules.”

Persephone Theadora Featherstonehaugh-Whittlemoore

Real estate broker, NAR Realtor, post-Sitzer compliance specialist

May 23, 2026

“Luxury sellers ask about commission breakdown more than any other client class. Your tool shows agent take-home AFTER brokerage split, which most calculators ignore. The 60/40 broker split preset matches our luxury-team contract exactly.”

Bartholomeus Christophe Ravenscroft-Pemberton

Listing-side broker, luxury market, Manhattan & Hamptons

May 4, 2026

“Commercial commission math is different from residential — sliding scale on larger deals, 80/20 brokerage splits typical. Your commercial preset captures the CCIM standard. The CRE flat percentage preset surfaces the proper math.”

Olufunmilayo Adesewa Ogundipe-Akinwale

CCIM-designated commercial broker, NAR-affiliated, Texas market

April 18, 2026

“Sellers using my flat-fee service want to understand exactly what they save vs traditional 6%. Your flat-fee preset alongside pre/post-Sitzer presets is the perfect side-by-side. Bookmarking this for buyer education emails.”

Aleksandr Mikhailovich Krzhizhanovsky-Bogachev

Flat-fee MLS service operator, FSBO + entry-level investor focus

March 27, 2026

Love using our calculator?